Best Baking Dishes: 8 Casserole Dishes for 9×13 Bakes
Eight casserole and baking dishes compared in glass, ceramic and cast iron.
Best overall: Pyrex Easy Grab. Best oven to table: Le Creuset Heritage. Best for broiling: Staub Ceramic Baker. Best for a crowd: Emile Henry Rectangular Baker.
A 9 by 13 inch baking dish is behind most casseroles, lasagnas and bar cookies. The material decides how it browns, how heavy it is and whether it can go under the broiler.
The best baking dish for most kitchens is the Pyrex Easy Grab 3-Quart with lid. For serving at the table, choose the Le Creuset Heritage, and for broiled tops pick the Staub ceramic baker.
All eight are sold on Amazon and compared on material, size and lid.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Baking Dishes Compared
All 8 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Baking dish | Material | Size | Lid | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pyrex Easy Grab 3-Quart Glass Baking Dish with Lid | Tempered glass | 3 qt, 9 x 13 in | Plastic lid | Casseroles, bars and storage | $ |
| OXO Good Grips 3-Quart Glass Baking Dish with Lid | Borosilicate glass | 3 qt, 9 x 13 in | Plastic lid | Make-ahead meals | $$ |
| Rubbermaid DuraLite Glass Baking Dish with Lid, 9 x 13 | Tempered glass | 2.5 qt, 9 x 13 in | Plastic lid | Lighter lifting | $ |
| Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Rectangular Casserole, 4-Quart | Enameled stoneware | 4 qt | No lid | Serving at the table | $$$ |
| Staub Ceramic Rectangular Baking Dish, 13 x 9 | Ceramic | 13 x 9 in | No lid | Crisp, browned tops | $$ |
| Emile Henry Modern Classics Large Rectangular Baker | Burgundy clay ceramic | Extra large, 13 x 9 in | No lid | Deep lasagna and crowds | $$$ |
| Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Lasagna Pan, Ceramic | Ceramic stoneware | Medium, about 13 x 9 in | No lid | Lighter ceramic | $$ |
| Lodge Cast Iron Casserole Pan, 9 x 13 | Seasoned cast iron | 9 x 13 in | No lid | Crisp crusts and grill use | $$ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ under $25 · $$ $25–70 · $$$ over $70.
The 8 Best Baking Dishes, Reviewed
Glass dishes first, then ceramic and cast iron.
Pyrex Easy Grab 3-Quart Glass Baking Dish with Lid
The classic that does nearly everything. Clear glass shows how the bottom is browning, and the lid turns the dish into a storage container.
Wide handles give a firm grip with oven mitts. Place it only in a preheated oven and keep it away from the broiler.
- Lowest price tier
- Lid for storage and travel
- Easy to see doneness
- Not broiler safe
- Avoid sudden temperature changes
OXO Good Grips 3-Quart Glass Baking Dish with Lid
Made for make-ahead cooking. Borosilicate glass handles temperature swings better than standard tempered glass, so it suits freezer meals.
The lid seals well for carrying. Check the listing for oven limits.
- Tolerates temperature change
- Secure lid
- Comfortable handles
- Not broiler safe
- Plain look
Rubbermaid DuraLite Glass Baking Dish with Lid, 9 x 13
Glass without the weight. It is noticeably lighter than most glass dishes, which helps when lifting a full pan.
It has no side handles, so use good oven mitts.
- Light to carry
- Low price tier
- Stacks neatly
- No handles
- Slightly smaller capacity
Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Rectangular Casserole, 4-Quart
A dish that looks good on the table. Dense stoneware holds heat, so a casserole stays warm through the meal.
The glaze resists stains and scratches and goes under the broiler for a browned top.
- Broiler safe
- Keeps food warm
- Many colors
- Top price tier
- Handles are small
Staub Ceramic Rectangular Baking Dish, 13 x 9
Ready for high heat. It goes under a hot broiler to crisp a gratin or brown cheese.
The glaze is smooth and releases baked-on food easily.
- Handles the broiler
- Sturdy handles
- Easy to clean
- Heavy
- Brand name on the handles
Emile Henry Modern Classics Large Rectangular Baker
The deep one. Tall sides hold a thick lasagna or a double batch of mac and cheese without bubbling over.
It is heavy when full, so lift with both hands.
- Very large capacity
- Even, gentle heat
- Durable glaze
- Heavy
- Small handles
Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Lasagna Pan, Ceramic
Ceramic that is easy to lift. It is lighter than most stoneware and has handles that are simple to hold.
Capacity is on the small side, so it suits standard recipes.
- Light for ceramic
- Good handles
- Clean white look
- Smaller capacity
- White shows stains
Lodge Cast Iron Casserole Pan, 9 x 13
For the crisp-edge fans. Cast iron browns the bottom and corners of cornbread, focaccia and baked pasta.
It works in the oven, under the broiler and on a grill. Dry it right after washing.
- Deep browning
- Nearly indestructible
- Any heat source
- Heavy
- Needs seasoning care
Glass vs Ceramic vs Cast Iron Baking Dishes
| Material | Good at | Keep in mind | Picks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Glass | Seeing doneness, low price, storage with a lid | No broiler, avoid thermal shock | Pyrex, OXO, Rubbermaid |
| Ceramic and stoneware | Holding heat, serving at the table | Heavier, higher price | Le Creuset, Staub, Emile Henry, Mrs. Anderson’s |
| Cast iron | Crisp crusts and very high heat | Heavy, needs seasoning | Lodge |
Glass dishes should go into a preheated oven and never under a broiler. Let a hot dish cool on a dry towel or rack, not a wet counter.
What Size Baking Dish Do I Need?
| Dish | Holds | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| 8 x 8 in | 2 qt | Brownies, small casseroles, sides for 4 |
| 11 x 7 in | 2 qt | Small lasagna, baked dips |
| 9 x 13 in | 3 qt | Standard casseroles, lasagna, sheet cakes |
| Deep 9 x 13 in | 4 to 5 qt | Deep lasagna and crowds |
Roasting meat? See the best roasting pans with racks. For cakes and bread, see the best cake pans and the best loaf pans.
How to Choose a Baking Dish
Five checks before you buy.
Glass, ceramic or iron
Glass is practical. Ceramic serves well. Cast iron crisps.
9 by 13 inches
Most recipes are written for a 3-quart dish.
Wide and easy to grip
Test the idea with oven mitts in mind.
For storage and travel
A lid saves foil and makes potlucks easier.
Check the listing
Ceramic and cast iron usually allow it. Glass does not.
More kitchen staples: the best stand mixers, the best countertop microwaves, the best stainless steel skillets and the best saucepans.
Baking Dish FAQs
What is the best baking dish?▼
The Pyrex Easy Grab 3-Quart with lid for most kitchens. It bakes evenly, shows doneness and stores leftovers.
Is glass or ceramic better for baking?▼
Glass is cheaper and lets you see the food. Ceramic holds heat longer and often handles the broiler.
What size is a standard casserole dish?▼
9 by 13 inches, which holds about 3 quarts.
Can a glass baking dish go under the broiler?▼
No. Direct broiler heat can crack glass. Use ceramic or cast iron instead.
Can I put a cold glass dish in a hot oven?▼
Avoid it with standard tempered glass. Let the dish come toward room temperature first, or use borosilicate glass and follow the maker’s directions.
What is the difference between a baking dish and a baking pan?▼
A baking dish is glass or ceramic. A baking pan is metal. Metal browns faster, so recipes may need small time changes.
How many quarts is a 9×13 dish?▼
About 3 quarts for a standard dish and 4 to 5 quarts for a deep one.
Do I need a baking dish with a lid?▼
A lid is useful for storage, freezer meals and travel. It is not needed for baking.
The Bottom Line
- Glass: Pyrex Easy Grab, OXO Glass Baking Dish and Rubbermaid DuraLite.
- Ceramic: Le Creuset Heritage, Staub Ceramic Baker, Emile Henry Rectangular Baker and Mrs. Anderson’s Lasagna Pan.
- Cast iron: Lodge Cast Iron Casserole.
Start with a 9 by 13 inch glass dish with a lid, then add a ceramic one for the table.
