Best Donut Pans: 6 Picks for Baked Donuts
Six donut pans compared in nonstick steel and silicone, from classic 6-cavity pans to mini and flower-shaped donuts.
Best overall: Wilton Donut Pans. Best value: Gezan Silicone Pans. Best mini: Norpro Mini Donut Pan. Best shapes: Webake Shaped Donut Pan.
A donut pan bakes cake-style donuts in the oven with no frying. Metal pans give golden edges; silicone pans make removal easy.
The best donut pan is the Wilton Non-Stick 6-Cavity Donut Pan two-pack, which bakes a dozen even, golden donuts. For the biggest batches, the Gezan silicone set bakes 18 at once.
All six are sold on Amazon and compared on capacity, donut size and material.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Donut Pans Compared
All 6 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Donut pan | Makes | Donut size | Material | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wilton Non-Stick 6-Cavity Donut Baking Pans, Set of 2 | 12 donuts (2 pans) | 3.25 in | Nonstick steel | Classic baked donuts | $ |
| Gezan Silicone Donut Baking Pans, Set of 3 | 18 donuts (3 pans) | 3 in | Silicone | Big batches | $ |
| Chefast Silicone Donut Pans Combo Kit with Mini Pan | 9 regular + 12 mini | 3.15 in and 1.85 in | Silicone | Regular and mini | $ |
| Tiawudi Non-Stick 6-Cavity Donut Baking Pans, Set of 3 | 18 donuts (3 pans) | 3.25 in | Nonstick carbon steel | Crowds and bake sales | $ |
| Norpro Nonstick Mini Donut Pan, 12 Count | 12 mini donuts | 2 in | Nonstick metal | Bite-size donuts | $ |
| Webake 12-Cavity Donut Pan with Flower and Fluted Shapes | 12 donuts, 3 shapes | 2.75 in | Nonstick carbon steel | Fancy shapes | $ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ under $25.
The 6 Best Donut Pans, Reviewed
Picks are drawn from Bob Vila’s donut pan guide, sorted from everyday pans to minis and shapes.
Wilton Non-Stick 6-Cavity Donut Baking Pans, Set of 2
The classic baked donut pan, sold as a pair. Two nonstick steel pans make a dozen 3.25-inch donuts per batch with even browning.
The listing says dishwasher safe, but hand washing keeps the coating in good shape longer.
- A dozen per batch
- Releases cleanly
- Low price tier
- Hand wash for best life
- Standard size only
Gezan Silicone Donut Baking Pans, Set of 3
Three silicone pans for the price of one metal set. They bake up to 18 donuts at once, and the donuts pop out with a gentle push.
Silicone is floppy, so set the pans on a sheet pan before filling and moving them.
- 18 at once
- Pops out easily
- Freezer and dishwasher safe
- Needs a sheet pan underneath
- Paler browning than metal
Chefast Silicone Donut Pans Combo Kit with Mini Pan
A starter kit with two sizes. A 9-well pan makes regular donuts and a 12-well pan makes bite-size ones, with a spatula and piping bags in the box.
Piping the batter keeps the center hole clean.
- Two donut sizes
- Piping bags included
- Oven safe to 446°F
- Needs a sheet pan underneath
- Bags are disposable
Tiawudi Non-Stick 6-Cavity Donut Baking Pans, Set of 3
Three metal pans for crowd-size batches. Carbon steel browns donuts better than silicone, and the set bakes 18 at a time.
Wash by hand to protect the nonstick coating.
- 18 per batch
- Better browning
- Low price tier
- Hand wash recommended
- Takes oven space
Norpro Nonstick Mini Donut Pan, 12 Count
Bite-size donuts for parties and lunch boxes. Twelve 2-inch wells bake quickly, and the pan comes with recipes.
Mini donuts bake in less time than regular ones, so start checking early.
- Party-size donuts
- Bakes fast
- Recipes included
- Small donuts only
- Watch the bake time
Webake 12-Cavity Donut Pan with Flower and Fluted Shapes
One pan, three looks. Four flower, four fluted and four classic wells make a mixed plate that looks bakery-made.
Grease the detailed shapes well so every ridge releases.
- Three shapes in one pan
- 12 per batch
- Low price tier
- Grease the ridges well
- Smaller than standard
Nonstick Steel or Silicone?
| Material | Good at | Keep in mind | Picks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nonstick steel | Golden edges, sturdy | Hand wash to protect the coating | Wilton, Tiawudi, Norpro, Webake |
| Silicone | Easy release, flexible | Needs a sheet pan; paler color | Gezan, Chefast |
Baked donuts are cake donuts. Yeast-raised donuts still need frying or an air fryer.
Tips for Perfect Baked Donuts
Grease every well
Even nonstick pans release better with a light coat of oil.
Pipe the batter
A piping bag or zip bag keeps the center post clean.
Fill two-thirds
Overfilled wells close the hole as the donut rises.
Do not overbake
Most bake in 9 to 12 minutes; minis take less.
Cool 5 minutes
Let them set in the pan, then turn out onto a rack.
Glaze warm
A warm donut takes glaze and sugar better.
Start with these donut recipes, try homemade donuts or air fryer donuts, and cool them on one of the best cooling racks.
How to Choose a Donut Pan
Five checks before you buy.
Steel or silicone
Steel browns better; silicone releases easier.
6, 12 or 18
Sets of two or three pans bake a full batch at once.
Regular or mini
About 3 inches for regular, 2 inches for minis.
Classic or fancy
Flower and fluted wells need extra greasing.
Hand wash nonstick
Hand washing keeps the coating working longer.
More baking guides: the best Instant Pot accessories, the best nakiri knives, the best cake decorating kits and the best cake carriers.
Donut Pan FAQs
What is the best donut pan?▼
The Wilton Non-Stick 6-Cavity Donut Pan two-pack, for even, golden baked donuts.
Are silicone or metal donut pans better?▼
Metal browns better; silicone releases easier. Set silicone pans on a sheet pan for support.
Do I need to grease a nonstick donut pan?▼
Yes, lightly. A thin coat of oil or baking spray gives a clean release.
How full should I fill a donut pan?▼
About two-thirds full, so the center hole stays open.
How long do baked donuts take?▼
About 9 to 12 minutes at 350°F for regular donuts, less for minis. Follow the recipe.
Can I make yeast donuts in a donut pan?▼
They bake, but come out like bread rolls. Donut pans suit cake-style batter.
Why are my baked donuts sticking?▼
The pan was not greased or the donuts were turned out too soon. Cool them 5 minutes first.
Can I use a donut pan for other bakes?▼
Yes. Try bagel-shaped egg bites, mini cakes or ring-shaped brownies.
The Bottom Line
- Everyday: Wilton Donut Pans; big batches: Gezan Silicone Pans and Tiawudi Donut Pans.
- Starter kit: Chefast Donut Kit.
- Minis and shapes: Norpro Mini Donut Pan and Webake Shaped Donut Pan.
Choose metal for color, silicone for easy release.
