Best Ice Cube Trays: 6 Lidded, Large and Sphere Picks
Six ice trays and molds compared, from lidded everyday trays to big 2-inch cubes, spheres and clear ice, plus tips for ice that tastes clean.
Best overall: OXO Covered Large Cube Tray. Best for everyday ice: DOQAUS 4-Pack. Best spheres: Tovolo Sphere Molds. Best clear ice: True Cubes Clear Ice.
A good tray releases cubes easily and keeps freezer smells out of your ice. A lid makes the biggest difference to how ice tastes.
The best ice cube tray is the OXO Good Grips Covered Silicone Tray, America’s Test Kitchen’s top cube mold. For lots of everyday ice, the DOQAUS 4-pack with lids is the easy pick.
All six are compared below on cube size, lid and material.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Ice Cube Trays Compared
All 6 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Ice tray | Cubes | Lid | Material | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OXO Good Grips Covered Silicone Ice Cube Tray, Large Cubes | Large 2-inch cubes | Yes | Silicone, plastic frame | Iced coffee and lemonade | $ |
| DOQAUS Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 4 Pack | 14 cubes per tray | Yes | Plastic, silicone bottoms | Families | $ |
| Tovolo King Cube Silicone Ice Cube Tray | Large 2-inch cubes | No | All silicone | Quick big cubes | $ |
| Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds, Set of 2 | Round spheres | Sealed top | Silicone and plastic | Slow-melting drinks | $ |
| True Cubes Clear Ice Cube Tray | Four 2-inch clear cubes | Insulated case | Silicone, plastic frame | Crystal-clear cubes | $$$ |
| Glacio Silicone Ice Cube Trays, Large Cube and Sphere Combo, 2 Pack | 6 cubes + 6 spheres | No | Silicone | Trying both shapes | $ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ under $15 · $$ $15–30 · $$$ over $30.
The 6 Best Ice Cube Trays, Reviewed
Picks draw on America’s Test Kitchen ice tray testing and This Old House’s top-rated trays.
OXO Good Grips Covered Silicone Ice Cube Tray, Large Cubes
America’s Test Kitchen’s top cube mold. Its rigid frame and lid made it easy to carry to the freezer without spills and cut down on freezer smells.
It makes large cubes only, so it is not the tray for filling a pitcher fast.
- No-spill carry
- Lid blocks odors
- Compact
- Large cubes only
- Fewer cubes per tray
DOQAUS Ice Cube Trays with Lids, 4 Pack
A four-pack for everyday ice. Press the silicone bottoms to pop out a few cubes at a time without twisting the whole tray.
This Old House named it best for spill prevention, though a few owners say the lids fit loosely.
- Pop out a few at a time
- Stacks in the freezer
- Low price tier
- Some lids fit loosely
- Small cubes melt faster
Tovolo King Cube Silicone Ice Cube Tray
Big cubes that pop out with almost no effort. America’s Test Kitchen found it especially easy to release.
With no frame or lid, water can slosh on the way to the freezer, and the silicone picked up freezer odors.
- Easiest release
- Big slow-melt cubes
- Low price tier
- No lid
- Absorbs odors
Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds, Set of 2
Molds for round ice that melts slowly. This Old House named them best for spheres, with a seal that keeps freezer odors out.
Each mold makes one sphere, and the first few tries can take practice.
- Slow-melting spheres
- Odor seal
- Low price tier
- One sphere per mold
- Takes practice
True Cubes Clear Ice Cube Tray
America’s Test Kitchen’s pick for clear ice. Its insulated frame freezes water slowly from the top down, which makes clear, glassy cubes.
It makes four cubes per batch, takes about 17 hours and a lot of freezer space, and the cloudy bottom layer has to be chipped off.
- Truly clear cubes
- Easy to carry
- Striking look
- Four cubes per batch
- Slow and bulky
Glacio Silicone Ice Cube Trays, Large Cube and Sphere Combo, 2 Pack
One large cube tray and one sphere tray in a single pack. This Old House named it the best combo pack for variety.
Cubes come out well, but owners say the sphere tray takes more care to get full rounds.
- Two shapes
- Easy-release silicone
- Low price tier
- Spheres take practice
- No lids
Which Ice Shape Should You Make?
| Ice type | Melts | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Standard cubes | Fastest | Pitchers, water bottles, quick chilling |
| Large 2-inch cubes | Slow | Iced coffee, lemonade and iced tea |
| Spheres | Slowest | Special drinks for guests |
| Clear ice | Slow | Drinks that look as good as they taste |
Bigger ice melts slower because less of its surface touches the drink. Try big cubes in homemade iced coffee or orange iced tea.
How to Make Better Ice at Home
Use filtered water
Cleaner water gives clearer, better-tasting ice.
Cover the tray
Lids keep freezer odors out of your ice.
Freeze coffee cubes
Coffee ice keeps iced coffee strong as it melts.
Wait a minute
Let silicone trays sit briefly, then push from below.
Store in a bin
Move cubes to a sealed bag or bin to free the tray.
Wash monthly
Soak silicone in warm, soapy water to clear odors.
Need more ice than trays can make? Compare the best countertop ice makers and the best nugget ice makers.
How to Choose an Ice Cube Tray
Five checks before you buy.
Big or small
Big cubes melt slowly; small cubes chill fast.
Covered is better
Lids stop spills and freezer smells.
Silicone or plastic
Silicone releases easily; plastic frames carry better.
Match your use
Families need more cubes per batch than one person.
Measure first
Clear ice molds and sphere sets are bulky.
More kitchen guides: the best meat cleavers, the best knife blocks, the best whetstones and the best paper towel holders.
Ice Cube Tray FAQs
What is the best ice cube tray?▼
The OXO Good Grips Covered Silicone Tray, America’s Test Kitchen’s top cube mold.
Silicone or plastic ice cube trays?▼
Silicone releases easily; plastic frames carry without spills. Trays with both work best.
Why does my ice taste like the freezer?▼
Uncovered ice absorbs odors. Use a tray with a lid and keep the freezer clean.
How do I make clear ice at home?▼
Use an insulated mold like True Cubes, which freezes water slowly from the top down.
How long does ice take to freeze?▼
Standard cubes take a few hours; big cubes take longer, and clear ice molds can take most of a day.
Are big ice cubes better?▼
For slow melting, yes. They chill a drink without watering it down as fast.
How do I get ice out of a silicone tray?▼
Let it sit a minute, then push each cube up from the bottom.
What else can I freeze in ice cube trays?▼
Coffee, fruit juice, broth, pesto and herbs in oil freeze well in small portions.
The Bottom Line
- Big cubes: OXO Covered Large Cube Tray and Tovolo King Cube.
- Everyday ice: DOQAUS 4-Pack.
- Spheres and clear ice: Tovolo Sphere Molds, Glacio Combo Pack and True Cubes Clear Ice.
Choose a tray with a lid and your ice will taste better.
