Best Pizza Stones and Steels: 7 Picks for Crisp Crusts
Seven pizza stones, steels and a cast iron pan compared, with stone vs steel, how long to preheat and how to clean them.
Best overall: Original Baking Steel. Best value steel: NerdChef Steel Stone. Best budget stone: Cook N Home Stone Tiles. Cast iron: Lodge Cast Iron Pizza Pan.
A home oven tops out far below a pizza oven. A preheated stone or steel stores heat and pushes it straight into the dough, so the base crisps before the toppings dry out.
The best pizza steel is the Original Baking Steel, which browns crusts evenly. For a lighter, low-cost option, choose the Cook N Home cordierite tile set.
All seven are sold on Amazon and compared on type, size and handling.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Pizza Stones and Steels Compared
All 7 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Stone or steel | Type | Size | Weight / handling | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Original Baking Steel, 16 x 14 x 1/4 Inch | Steel | 16 x 14 in | 16 lb | Crisp, evenly browned crusts | $$$ |
| NerdChef Steel Stone, Standard 1/4 Inch | Steel | 16 x 14.25 in | Heavy | Pizza and bread | $$ |
| Dough-Joe Pizza Steel Baking Sheet, The Samurai, 15 x 15 Inch | Steel | 15 x 15 in | Lighter than the top steels | Round pies with room to spare | $$ |
| Cook N Home Pizza Grilling Stone Set, 6 Tiles | Cordierite stone tiles | 21.5 x 15 in total | Light tiles | Small budgets, easy storage | $ |
| Honey-Can-Do 14 x 16 Inch Cordierite Pizza Stone | Cordierite stone | 16 x 14 in | Fairly light for a stone | Classic stone baking | $ |
| Rocksheat Pizza Stone with Handles, 16 x 14 Inch | Cordierite stone | 16 x 14 in | Built-in handle flaps | Oven and grill | $ |
| Lodge Cast Iron Pizza Pan, 14 Inch | Cast iron | 14 in round | Loop handles | Oven, grill and stovetop | $ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ under $50 · $$ $50–100 · $$$ over $100.
The 7 Best Pizza Stones and Steels, Reviewed
Picks are drawn from America’s Test Kitchen testing of stones and steels.
The Original Baking Steel, 16 x 14 x 1/4 Inch
A slab of steel that turns a home oven into a pizzeria. Steel moves heat into dough faster than stone, so crusts brown evenly and stay tender inside.
It weighs 16 pounds, so it is best left on an oven rack. It also works as a griddle on the stovetop.
- Fast, even browning
- Will not crack
- Doubles as a griddle
- Heavy at 16 lb
- Top price tier
NerdChef Steel Stone, Standard 1/4 Inch
The other top steel in America’s Test Kitchen testing. It browns crusts uniformly and keeps them moist inside.
Like any quarter-inch steel, it is heavy, so slide it in once and leave it.
- Uniform browning
- Moist crumb
- Middle price tier
- Hard to lift
- Needs occasional oiling
Dough-Joe Pizza Steel Baking Sheet, The Samurai, 15 x 15 Inch
A square steel with a little more room. It performs like the top steels but weighs a bit less.
The square shape fits a round pizza with space around the edge for turning.
- Top-steel results
- A bit lighter
- Square shape
- Still heavy
- Check oven rack depth
Cook N Home Pizza Grilling Stone Set, 6 Tiles
A stone you can store in a drawer. Six light tiles cover a large area and lift out one at a time.
Crusts come out a little chewier than on steel, but the price and easy handling make it a smart first stone.
- Light and easy to store
- Covers a large area
- Lowest price tier
- Chewier crust than steel
- Tiles can shift
Honey-Can-Do 14 x 16 Inch Cordierite Pizza Stone
A classic one-piece stone. It browns well and is fairly light for its size.
Crusts run slightly drier than on steel. Preheat it for at least 45 minutes.
- Good browning
- Fairly light
- Low price tier
- Slightly drier crust
- Can crack with sudden temperature changes
Rocksheat Pizza Stone with Handles, 16 x 14 Inch
A stone with handles. Built-in flaps on the sides make it easier to lift in and out of the oven or grill.
Crusts are a bit drier than on steel, but it is a good fit for grilling pizza outdoors.
- Easy to lift
- Grill friendly
- Low price tier
- Slightly drier crust
- Heavy for a stone
Lodge Cast Iron Pizza Pan, 14 Inch
A round pan that acts like a stone. Pre-seasoned cast iron holds heat for a crisp crust and will not crack.
Loop handles make it easy to carry from the oven to the table, and it works on the grill and stovetop too.
- Will not crack
- Easy to carry
- Low price tier
- Heavy
- Needs seasoning care
Pizza Stone vs Pizza Steel
| Type | Good at | Keep in mind | Picks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pizza steel | Fastest browning, will not crack | Heavy | Baking Steel, NerdChef, Dough-Joe |
| Cordierite stone | Classic crust, lighter | Can crack; slightly drier crust | Honey-Can-Do, Rocksheat, Cook N Home |
| Cast iron pan | Durable, easy to carry | Smaller round surface | Lodge |
Steel bakes faster and browns more; stone is lighter and gives a slightly drier, classic crust.
Want more heat? Compare the best countertop pizza ovens and the best outdoor pizza ovens.
How to Preheat and Care for a Stone or Steel
Preheat long
Heat the oven with the stone or steel inside for 45 to 60 minutes.
Top rack for steel
An upper rack under the broiler browns the top and bottom together.
Never wash stone with soap
Scrape and brush it. Soap soaks in.
Oil steel lightly
Wipe on a thin coat of oil now and then to prevent rust.
Cool in the oven
Let stones cool slowly to avoid cracks.
Stains are normal
Dark spots on a stone do not affect baking.
Bake with these homemade pizza recipes.
How to Choose a Pizza Stone or Steel
Five checks before you buy.
Steel or stone
Steel browns fastest and will not crack. Stone is lighter.
Measure the oven
Leave an inch of space around the edges for airflow.
Can you lift it?
Quarter-inch steels weigh around 15 lb.
Check the maker
Cordierite and cast iron handle grill heat well.
Leave it in the oven
A steel can live on the bottom rack.
More baking guides: the best braisers, the best paella pans, the best tagine pots and the best stovetop tea kettles.
Pizza Stone and Steel FAQs
Is a pizza steel better than a pizza stone?▼
For browning, yes. Steel transfers heat faster and will not crack. Stone is lighter and costs less.
What is the best pizza stone?▼
The Honey-Can-Do 14 x 16 Inch Cordierite Pizza Stone for a classic stone, or the Cook N Home tiles on a budget.
How long should I preheat a pizza stone?▼
45 to 60 minutes at the oven’s highest setting.
Can I put a pizza stone on the grill?▼
Cordierite stones and cast iron pans can go on a grill. Heat them slowly.
How do I clean a pizza stone?▼
Let it cool, scrape off stuck bits and brush it with water. Do not use soap.
Why did my pizza stone crack?▼
Sudden temperature changes. Do not put a cold stone in a hot oven or run water over a hot stone.
Can I use a pizza steel on the stove?▼
Yes. Steel works as a griddle on the stovetop.
Where should the stone go in the oven?▼
The upper third for steel, the lower third for stone. Adjust if the top browns before the base.
The Bottom Line
- Steels: Original Baking Steel, NerdChef Steel Stone and Dough-Joe Samurai Steel.
- Stones: Honey-Can-Do Pizza Stone, Rocksheat Pizza Stone and Cook N Home Stone Tiles.
- Cast iron: Lodge Cast Iron Pizza Pan.
Steel for the crispest crust, stone for less weight.
