Best Cake Carriers: 5 Picks for Cakes, Cupcakes and Pies
Five cake and pie carriers compared on locking lids, cupcake inserts, pie depth and how steady they ride in a car.
Best overall: Progressive Cake Carrier. Best budget: Wilton Cake Caddy. Best for pies: Prepworks Party Carrier.
A cake carrier protects hours of baking on the way to the party. Look for a lid that locks, a base that does not slide and enough height for the frosting.
The best cake carrier is the Progressive Collapsible Cupcake and Cake Carrier, which holds a 9-inch layer cake or 24 cupcakes under a locking lid. For pies, choose the Prepworks Collapsible Party Carrier.
All five are sold on Amazon and compared on what they hold, how they close and price tier.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Cake Carriers Compared
All 5 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Carrier | Holds | Lid | Build | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive Collapsible Cupcake and Cake Carrier | 9 in round or square cake, or 24 cupcakes | Locking | Collapsible plastic | Layer cakes and cupcakes | $$ |
| Wilton Portable Cake Caddy | Round cakes | Latches | Plastic | Short trips | $ |
| Rubbermaid Servin’ Saver Cake Keeper | Round cakes | No lock | Plastic | Keeping cake fresh at home | $ |
| Prepworks by Progressive Collapsible Party Carrier | 8, 9 or 10 in pie, up to about 6.5 in tall | Latches | Collapsible plastic | Pies and potlucks | $$ |
| Pyrex Portables Pie Carrier with 9-Inch Pie Plate | 9 in pie, plate included | Lid | Glass plate, carrier | Bake and carry | $$ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ under $20 · $$ $20–40.
The 5 Best Cake Carriers, Reviewed
Picks are drawn from America’s Test Kitchen testing of cake carriers and pie carriers.
Progressive Collapsible Cupcake and Cake Carrier
The cake carrier America’s Test Kitchen ranks first. It holds a 9-inch round or square layer cake, or up to two dozen cupcakes with the insert, under a lid that locks firmly.
Comfortable handles make it easy to carry, and it collapses for storage. It is dishwasher safe.
- Sturdy locking lid
- Cupcake insert
- Collapses to store
- Plastic, not insulated
- Middle price tier
Wilton Portable Cake Caddy
A simple carrier with latches that keep the lid on. It protects a frosted cake for a short trip at a low price.
Testers found the thin handle uncomfortable, and the smooth base can slide in a car, so set it on a towel or non-slip mat.
- Lid latches on
- Low price tier
- Dishwasher safe
- Thin handle
- Base can slide
Rubbermaid Servin’ Saver Cake Keeper
A keeper more than a carrier. The dome keeps a cake fresh on the counter, and cakes stayed in place in testing.
It has no lock and no handles, so carry it with both hands.
- Keeps cake fresh
- Low price tier
- Simple to clean
- No locking lid
- No handles
Prepworks by Progressive Collapsible Party Carrier
The pie carrier America’s Test Kitchen ranks first. It holds an 8- to 10-inch pie up to about 6.5 inches tall, and the insert flips to carry two shorter pies or up to 28 deviled eggs.
A large non-slip base kept pies steady on bumpy roads. The latches take a little care to close.
- Fits tall meringue pies
- Two pies or deviled eggs
- Non-slip base
- Latches need care
- Takes shelf space when open
Pyrex Portables Pie Carrier with 9-Inch Pie Plate
A carrier that comes with the pie plate. Bake in the glass plate, then set it in the carrier, which has shallow recesses that make lifting the pie out easy.
It is too shallow for very tall meringue pies.
- Pie plate included
- Easy to lift out
- Good value
- Too shallow for tall pies
- Best with its own plate
Cake Carrier, Cake Keeper or Pie Carrier?
| Type | Good for | Watch for | Picks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Locking cake carrier | Frosted layer cakes and cupcakes | Lid height for tall cakes | Progressive, Wilton |
| Cake keeper | Storing cake at home | No lock for travel | Rubbermaid |
| Pie carrier | Pies, tarts and deviled eggs | Depth for meringue | Prepworks, Pyrex |
Measure the frosted cake before buying; tall layer cakes need a tall lid.
How to Transport a Cake in the Car
Chill it first
A cold cake is firmer and the frosting holds its shape.
Lock the lid
Check every latch before lifting by the handle.
Floor, not seat
The flat car floor is steadier than a sloped seat.
Use a non-slip mat
A rubber mat or damp towel stops sliding.
Add a cake board
A board under the cake makes it easy to lift out.
Pack extra frosting
A small bag of frosting fixes scuffs on arrival.
Bake it in the best cake pans, carry a pie made in one of the best pie dishes, and serve it on one of the best cake stands.
How to Choose a Cake Carrier
Five checks before you buy.
Fit the cake
Most carriers fit a 9-inch round; check the height for tall layers.
Locks, not just snaps
Latches on every side keep the lid on if it tips.
Non-slip
A grippy base stays put in the car.
Comfortable
A wide handle is easier to carry a heavy cake.
Collapsible
Collapsible carriers save cupboard space.
More baking guides: the best pasta makers, the best Instant Pot accessories, the best nakiri knives and the best cake decorating kits.
Cake Carrier FAQs
What is the best cake carrier?▼
The Progressive Collapsible Cupcake and Cake Carrier, which holds a 9-inch layer cake or 24 cupcakes under a locking lid.
What size cake carrier do I need?▼
One that fits a 9-inch round with room above the frosting. Measure the cake height first.
Can I carry cupcakes in a cake carrier?▼
Yes, if it has a cupcake insert. The Progressive carrier holds up to 24.
How do I keep a cake from sliding in the car?▼
Use a carrier with a non-slip base and set it on the car floor on a rubber mat or damp towel.
What is the difference between a cake keeper and a carrier?▼
A keeper stores cake at home; a carrier locks for travel. Keepers usually have no handles.
Can a cake carrier hold a pie?▼
Yes, but a pie carrier fits better. The Prepworks carrier holds tall pies and deviled eggs.
Are cake carriers dishwasher safe?▼
Most plastic carriers are. Check the listing; collapsible parts may need hand washing.
How long can a frosted cake sit in a carrier?▼
A few hours at cool room temperature. Refrigerate cream or cream cheese frostings.
The Bottom Line
- Cakes and cupcakes: Progressive Cake Carrier; budget: Wilton Cake Caddy.
- At home: Rubbermaid Servin’ Saver.
- Pies: Prepworks Party Carrier and Pyrex Pie Carrier.
Pick a locking carrier for travel and a simple keeper for the counter.
