Best Popsicle Molds: 6 Picks for Homemade Ice Pops
Six ice pop molds compared on easy release, drips and cleanup, from America’s Test Kitchen’s winner to steel molds and 10-pop party sets.
Best overall: Zoku Classic Pop Molds. Best for kids: Tovolo Groovy Pop Molds. Best for a crowd: Norpro Ice Pop Maker. Fastest: Zoku Quick Pop Maker.
The best popsicle molds fill without spills and let each pop slide out whole. Detachable molds let everyone take one pop at a time.
The best popsicle mold is the Zoku Classic Pop Molds, America’s Test Kitchen’s winner for easy filling, release and cleaning. For layered pops, the Onyx stainless mold or Norpro 10-pop maker works best.
All six are compared below on pops per batch, material and sticks.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Popsicle Molds Compared
All 6 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Pop mold | Pops | Material | Sticks | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zoku Classic Pop Molds, Set of 6 | 6 pops | Plastic | Reusable, drip guards | Easy everyday pops | $$ |
| Onyx Containers Stainless Steel Ice Pop Mold, 6 Pops | 6 pops | Stainless steel | Wooden sticks | Layered pops | $$$ |
| Tovolo Groovy Ice Pop Molds, Set of 6 | 6 pops | Plastic | Reusable, deep drip guards | Little hands | $ |
| Norpro Frozen Ice Pop Maker, 10 Pops | 10 pops | Plastic and aluminum | Wooden sticks | Parties and layers | $ |
| Zoku Quick Pop Maker | 3 pops per round | Pre-frozen base | Reusable | Pops in minutes | $$$ |
| Cuisipro Snap-Fit Square Ice Pop Mold Set | 6 pops | Plastic | Reusable | Tight freezers | $$ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ under $15 · $$ $15–30 · $$$ over $30.
The 6 Best Popsicle Molds, Reviewed
Picks draw on America’s Test Kitchen ice pop mold testing with lemonade and layered pops.
Zoku Classic Pop Molds, Set of 6
America’s Test Kitchen’s top pick, called the easiest to use of all the molds tested. Detachable molds with fill lines and wide openings make filling and cleaning easy.
The slim drip guards are fixed in place, so layered pops are not possible.
- Easiest to use
- One pop at a time
- Easy to clean
- No layered pops
- Plastic sticks only
Onyx Containers Stainless Steel Ice Pop Mold, 6 Pops
A stainless steel mold for cooks cutting back on plastic. Removable lids make layered pops relatively easy.
Lids can shift on the way to the freezer, so sticks sometimes set crooked, and it is not dishwasher safe.
- Steel instead of plastic
- Great for layers
- Built to last
- Sticks can tilt
- Hand wash only
Tovolo Groovy Ice Pop Molds, Set of 6
Wide-mouthed molds that stand upright on the counter. Deep drip guards catch melting juice, which helps with small kids.
The guards get in the way of the last bites, and the smooth handle is slippery with wet hands.
- Easy to fill
- Catches drips
- Low price tier
- Guards block last bites
- Slippery handle
Norpro Frozen Ice Pop Maker, 10 Pops
Ten pops at once in a classic frame. America’s Test Kitchen called it a good low-cost option for layered pops.
Narrow molds are harder to fill and clean, and the pops release all at once rather than one by one.
- Makes 10 pops
- Good for layers
- Low price tier
- Harder to clean
- All pops release together
Zoku Quick Pop Maker
A pre-frozen base that sets pops in minutes instead of hours. Pops freeze right on the counter, so kids can make and eat them the same afternoon.
The base needs about 24 hours in the freezer first, and America’s Test Kitchen still preferred the simpler Classic molds.
- Pops in minutes
- Fun for kids
- Creative designs
- Freeze base 24 hours
- Top price tier
Cuisipro Snap-Fit Square Ice Pop Mold Set
Square molds that snap together in different shapes. They can be arranged to fit a crowded freezer shelf.
America’s Test Kitchen found the drip guard in the way and the ring handle small for larger hands.
- Fits crowded freezers
- Fairly easy release
- Reusable sticks
- Small handles
- Drip guard in the way
Easy Homemade Popsicle Ideas
| Pop | What to use | Tip |
|---|---|---|
| Fruit juice pops | Fruit juice, or juice and water | Add chopped fruit for texture |
| Yogurt pops | Yogurt, fruit and a little maple syrup | Stir well for smooth pops |
| Smoothie pops | Leftover smoothie | Blend it thick so it does not separate |
| Lemonade pops | Fresh lemonade | Drop in berries before freezing |
| Layered pops | Two colors of fruit puree | Freeze each layer 30 to 45 minutes |
Fruit puree and yogurt make softer pops than thin juice. Start with these yogurt popsicle recipes or a mango yogurt smoothie.
How to Get Pops Out of the Mold
Leave headspace
Fill to the line so pops can expand.
Freeze long enough
Most pops need 4 to 6 hours, or overnight.
Warm water dip
Run the mold under warm water for 10 to 20 seconds.
Wiggle, do not yank
Twist the stick gently once the edges loosen.
Bag them up
Move unmolded pops to a freezer bag to free the mold.
Wash right away
Sticky juice cleans off easier before it dries.
Love frozen treats? See the best ice cream makers, the best home slushie machines and the best personal smoothie blenders.
How to Choose a Popsicle Mold
Five checks before you buy.
One at a time
Detachable molds let each person take one pop.
Plastic, silicone or steel
Steel lasts longest; plastic costs least.
Reusable or wooden
Wooden sticks allow layers; reusable sticks save waste.
Built-in guards
Drip guards help small kids.
Match the crowd
Six suits a family; ten suits a party.
More summer treat guides: the best knife blocks, the best whetstones, the best paper towel holders and the best ice cube trays.
Popsicle Mold FAQs
What is the best popsicle mold?▼
The Zoku Classic Pop Molds, America’s Test Kitchen’s top pick for easy filling, release and cleaning.
How long do homemade popsicles take to freeze?▼
About 4 to 6 hours, or overnight for firm pops. The Zoku Quick Pop Maker sets pops in minutes.
How do I get popsicles out of the mold?▼
Run the mold under warm water for 10 to 20 seconds, then twist the stick gently.
Silicone, plastic or stainless steel molds?▼
Plastic costs least, silicone peels away easily and steel lasts longest.
How do I make layered popsicles?▼
Freeze each layer 30 to 45 minutes before adding the next, then add the sticks.
Why are my popsicles icy?▼
Thin juice freezes hard and icy. Fruit puree or yogurt makes softer pops.
Can I use wooden sticks in any mold?▼
Only in molds with stick-holding lids, such as the Norpro or Onyx.
How long do homemade popsicles keep?▼
About 1 to 2 months in a sealed freezer bag for the best flavor.
The Bottom Line
- Top pick: Zoku Classic Pop Molds; kids: Tovolo Groovy Pop Molds.
- Layers: Onyx Stainless Pop Mold and Norpro Ice Pop Maker.
- Fast or compact: Zoku Quick Pop Maker and Cuisipro Snap-Fit Pop Molds.
Detachable molds make the easiest pops for busy families.
