Chest Freezer vs Upright Freezer: Which One Should You Buy?
Chest freezer vs upright freezer compared on space, capacity, energy use, organization and power outages, with picks of each and a clear verdict.
A chest freezer is the better buy for the most storage at the lowest running cost. An upright freezer is the better buy for small floor space and food you can see and reach.
Cold air sinks, so a chest freezer loses little when the lid opens. An upright spills cold air each time the door opens, but everything sits on shelves at eye level.
Choose a chest freezer such as the GE 7.0 Cu Ft for bulk meat, garden produce and a garage. Choose an upright freezer such as the Frigidaire 6.5 Cu Ft for a kitchen, pantry or apartment where floor space is tight.
The chart and six picks are below.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Chest and Upright Freezers Compared
All 6 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Freezer | Type | Capacity | Defrost | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Midea 3.5 Cu Ft Chest Freezer | Chest | 3.5 cu ft | Manual defrost | Apartments and overflow | $ |
| GE 7.0 Cu Ft Garage Ready Chest Freezer | Chest | 7.0 cu ft | Manual defrost | Garages and bulk buying | $$ |
| Hisense 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer | Chest | 7.0 cu ft | Manual defrost | Families | $$ |
| Midea 3.0 Cu Ft Upright Freezer | Upright | 3.0 cu ft | Manual defrost | Small spaces | $ |
| Frigidaire 6.5 Cu Ft Upright Freezer | Upright | 6.5 cu ft | See listing | Families in small homes | $$ |
| Frost-Free Upright Freezer, 13 to 16 Cu Ft | Upright | 13 to 16 cu ft | Frost-free | Large households | $$$ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ lowest in this group · $$ middle · $$$ highest.
3 Chest Freezers and 3 Upright Freezers, Reviewed
Capacities are from the makers. Check each listing for size and garage rating.
Midea 3.5 Cu Ft Chest Freezer
A compact chest freezer. It holds a lot for its price tier and keeps food frozen longer than an upright if the power fails.
- Low price tier
- Holds cold well
- Quiet
- Food stacks in layers
- Manual defrost
GE 7.0 Cu Ft Garage Ready Chest Freezer
A mid-size chest freezer rated by the maker for garage use. Seven cubic feet suits a family that buys meat in bulk or freezes garden produce.
Check the listing for the temperature range.
- Garage rated
- Good capacity
- Baskets for small items
- Needs floor space
- Manual defrost
Hisense 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer
A 7 cubic foot chest freezer in the middle price tier. A front drain makes the yearly defrost quicker.
- Good value per cubic foot
- Defrost drain
- Simple
- One basket
- Manual defrost
Midea 3.0 Cu Ft Upright Freezer
A compact upright the size of a mini fridge. Shelves keep every item in view, and it uses very little floor space.
- Small footprint
- Easy to organize
- Low price tier
- Less storage per dollar than a chest
- Manual defrost
Frigidaire 6.5 Cu Ft Upright Freezer
A slim mid-size upright. It stores about as much as a 7 cubic foot chest on roughly half the floor space.
- Small footprint for its capacity
- Door bins
- Food stays visible
- Costs more per cubic foot
- Loses cold faster when opened
Check Frigidaire 6.5 Cu Ft Upright Freezer Price on Amazon →
Frost-Free Upright Freezer, 13 to 16 Cu Ft
A full-size frost-free upright. Automatic defrost means no yearly chipping of ice, which no standard chest freezer offers.
Compare models and check the garage rating.
- No manual defrosting
- Large and organized
- Interior light
- Top price tier
- Uses more energy than a chest
Chest Freezer vs Upright Freezer: Side by Side
| Chest freezer | Upright freezer | |
|---|---|---|
| Floor space | More | Less |
| Usable capacity | Nearly all of it | Some lost to shelves and bins |
| Organization | Layers and baskets | Shelves and door bins |
| Energy use | Lower | Higher, more so if frost-free |
| In a power outage | Stays cold longer | Warms faster |
| Defrost | Manual | Manual or frost-free |
| Price per cubic foot | Lower | Higher |
| Reaching food | Bend and dig | Eye level |
A full freezer that stays closed keeps food frozen for about 48 hours without power, and a half-full one for about 24 hours.
Who Should Buy Which?
Buy a chest freezer for bulk buying
Large cuts and whole turkeys fit without shelves in the way.
Buy an upright for a small home
It needs about half the floor space.
Buy a chest freezer where power cuts are common
It holds its cold longer.
Buy an upright if bending is hard
Food sits at eye level.
Buy a chest freezer for the lowest running cost
It uses less energy for the same capacity.
Buy a frost-free upright to skip defrosting
Chest freezers need a yearly manual defrost.
See the best chest freezers and the top upright freezers for more picks.
What to Check Before You Buy
Five things to check.
Floor or height
Chests need floor, uprights need height.
Cubic feet
About 1.5 cubic feet per person is a common guide.
Garage rating
Check the temperature range.
Manual or frost-free
Frost-free costs more to buy and run.
Who uses it
Uprights are easier on backs.
More freezer guides: the best chest freezers, the top upright freezers, what temperature a freezer should be and freezer thermometers with alarms.
Chest vs Upright Freezer FAQs
Is a chest freezer or an upright freezer better?▼
A chest freezer for capacity and running cost, an upright for convenience and small spaces.
Which uses less electricity?▼
A chest freezer. It loses less cold air when opened and has thicker insulation for its size.
Which keeps food frozen longer in a power outage?▼
A chest freezer. Keep either closed: a full freezer holds for about 48 hours.
Which lasts longer?▼
Both commonly last 10 years or more. Manual-defrost models have fewer parts.
Do upright freezers cause more freezer burn?▼
Frost-free models can, because the defrost cycle warms the air slightly. Wrap food tightly.
Which is better for a garage?▼
Either, if it is rated garage ready. Check the listing for the temperature range.
How do I organize a chest freezer?▼
Use baskets and bins by food type and keep a list on the lid.
What size freezer does a family of four need?▼
About 6 to 7 cubic feet as a second freezer, more for bulk meat buyers.
The Bottom Line
- Bulk storage and garages: GE 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer.
- Small budgets: Midea 3.5 Cu Ft Chest Freezer.
- Tight floor space: Frigidaire 6.5 Cu Ft Upright Freezer.
- Apartments: Midea 3.0 Cu Ft Upright Freezer.
- No defrosting: Full-Size Frost-Free Upright.
Chest for capacity and low running cost, upright for space and easy access.
