★ Black Friday · Fri Nov 27★ Cyber Monday · Mon Nov 30★ Shop the deals →★ Gift guides for every cook★ See the gift guides →★ Black Friday · Fri Nov 27★ Cyber Monday · Mon Nov 30★ Shop the deals →★ Gift guides for every cook★ See the gift guides →

Canning Pumpkin Pie Filling: Can the Pumpkin, Not the Filling

Table of Contents

Canning Pumpkin Pie Filling: Can the Pumpkin, Not the Filling

The USDA-tested way to can pumpkin for pie: sugar pumpkin cubes, a pressure canner and an altitude chart, then the 9-inch pie you make from the jar.

  • Pints: 55 min
  • Quarts: 90 min
  • Hot pack only
  • Freezer option too
Canning pumpkin pie filling the safe way: rows of pint jars of bright orange pumpkin cubes in clear liquid on a wooden pantry shelf beside a small sugar pumpkin

The pantry shelf to aim for: pint jars of plain pumpkin cubes in clear liquid, sealed and labeled, with a small sugar pumpkin beside them.

Canning pumpkin pie filling is the one pumpkin job USDA’s home canning guide says to skip: there is no tested process for filling, purée or pumpkin butter. What does work is canning the pumpkin itself, as plain 1-inch cubes in a pressure canner, then mashing and seasoning it on pie day.

Quick answer

Don’t can the filling, purée or pumpkin butter: there is no tested home process. Can 1-inch cubes of sugar pumpkin instead: boil 2 minutes, pack hot in the cooking liquid with 1 inch of headspace and pressure-can pints 55 minutes, quarts 90 (10 lb weighted or 11 lb dial gauge at low altitude). On pie day, drain, mash and bake.

Why the filling itself can’t go in the jar

Pie filling, purée and mashed pumpkin are thick, and their thickness changes from batch to batch. Heat reaches the center of the jar slowly and unpredictably, so no processing time can promise that every jar gets hot enough. Under-processed low-acid food carries a botulism risk.

USDA’s Complete Guide to Home Canning and the National Center for Home Food Preservation both advise against canning pumpkin purée or filling at home, and lemon or apple juice does not change that. Plain cubes in liquid heat predictably, and that is the method on this page.

On this page

  • The canning card: 4 pints, 9 pints or 7 quarts
  • Altitude chart for weighted and dial gauges
  • Pie filling made from the jar
  • Canned pumpkin vs canned pie filling
  • Freezing, storage and seals
  • 14 quick answers

Why Canning Pumpkin Pie Filling Isn’t a Tested Recipe, and What Is

Canning times come from lab tests on one specific food, cut and jar size, and pumpkin has exactly one tested form. Four reasons the filling stays out of the jar:

Too thick to heat evenly

Purée is dense, and its thickness changes with the pumpkin, the cooking and the sugar. Heat creeps into the center slowly, so no single time fits every jar.

No tested time exists

Safe times come from lab tests that track the slowest-heating spot in a jar. Purée, pie filling and pumpkin butter have no recommended time at all.

Juice does not make it safe

Pumpkin is low-acid. A splash of lemon or apple juice is not a tested amount, does not help a thick purée heat through and never makes it a water-bath recipe.

Eggs, milk and flour stay out

Dairy, eggs, cream, flour and thickeners never go into home-canned pumpkin. They belong to pie day, whisked into freshly mashed pumpkin.

Can It Be Canned at Home?

Pumpkin productHome canning?Do this instead
Pumpkin productPumpkin or winter squash in 1-inch cubesHome canning?Yes in a pressure cannerDo this insteadPints 55 min, quarts 90 min; the card above
Pumpkin productMashed or puréed pumpkinHome canning?No tested processDo this insteadFreeze it, or mash canned cubes after opening
Pumpkin productPumpkin pie fillingHome canning?No tested processDo this insteadFreeze the filling or the baked pie
Pumpkin productPumpkin butterHome canning?No tested processDo this insteadKeep it in the fridge or freezer
Pumpkin productAny pumpkin in a water-bath cannerHome canning?No not safeDo this insteadPressure canner only

The short version: can the pumpkin, freeze the filling. Cubes give a shelf-stable pantry staple; the freezer handles anything already mashed, sweetened or mixed.

Canning Pumpkin for Pie: How to Can Pumpkin Cubes in a Pressure Canner

Searching how to cook a pie pumpkin, can it and turn it into pie filling? The work splits into three stages that can sit months apart:

  1. Canning dayCube, boil 2 minutes, pack and pressure-can plain pumpkin.
  2. On the shelfSealed jars wait in a cool, dark pantry for up to a year.
  3. Pie dayDrain, mash, thicken, season and bake one 9-inch pie per quart.

The card is set for a full load of 9 pints; tap 4 pints or 7 quarts and the pumpkin, jars and time change.

Pressure-Canned Pumpkin Cubes for Pie

The tested way to can pumpkin: plain 1-inch cubes, hot-packed in their cooking water and pressure canned. The pie filling comes later, from the drained jar.

How big a batch?

  • Prepabout 1 hr
  • Boil2 min
  • Process55 min55 min90 min
  • Headspace1 inch
  • Makes4 pints9 pints7 quarts

Ingredients

  • about 4½ lb (2 kg)about 10 lb (4.5 kg)about 16 lb (7.3 kg) small sugar or pie pumpkins, firm, with hard rinds (weighed whole)
  • Plenty of water, for boiling the cubes and filling the jars
  • Nothing else: no sugar, spice, salt, lemon or juice. The tested process is plain pumpkin in water.
Equipment
  • 1 pressure canner that holds at least 4 quart jars, with a weighted gauge or a dial gauge tested this year
  • 497 pintpintquart canning jars, with new flat lids and bands
  • 1 large pot, slotted spoon, ladle and wide-mouth funnel
  • 1 jar lifter, bubble tool or thin plastic spatula, clean towels and labels

Pressure canner only: not a water-bath or steam canner, oven, slow cooker, multicooker or small pressure cooker. Pressure by altitude: weighted gauge 10 lb up to 1,000 ft, 15 lb above; dial gauge 11 lb up to 2,000 ft, 12 lb to 4,000, 13 lb to 6,000, 14 lb to 8,000.

Instructions

  1. Get the canner and jars ready

    Check the gasket and vent pipe; a dial gauge should be tested this year. Wash the jars, lids and bands in hot, soapy water and keep the jars hot. Pressure-canned jars need no sterilizing.

  2. Seed, peel and cube

    Wash the pumpkins, halve them and scrape out the seeds and strings. Cut 1-inch-wide slices, peel them, then cut the flesh into 1-inch cubes. Do not mash or purée.

  3. Boil the cubes 2 minutes

    Boil the cubes in a large pot of water for 2 minutes, in batches if the pot is crowded. Keep them in their hot cooking liquid.

  4. Fill hot jars, 1-inch headspace

    Spoon the hot cubes into the hot jars without pressing them down, then ladle in hot cooking liquid to cover, leaving 1 inch of headspace.

  5. Release bubbles, wipe, lid

    Run a bubble tool around each jar and top up to the 1-inch line. Wipe the rims, center the lids and screw the bands on fingertip-tight.

  6. Load and vent 10 minutes

    Set the jars on the canner rack with 2 to 3 inches of hot water, or as the manual directs. Lock the lid, heat on high until steam flows from the vent and vent for 10 full minutes.

  7. Bring to pressure and process

    Put on the weight or close the petcock. Start timing at your pressure (10 lb weighted or 11 lb dial gauge up to 1,000 ft; higher up, see the altitude note) and process 555590 minutes. If the pressure dips, bring it back and restart the time from zero.

  8. Let the pressure drop on its own

    Turn off the heat and let the canner fall to zero by itself; never cool it with water. Remove the weight or open the petcock, wait 10 minutes, then open the lid away from your face.

  9. Cool 12 to 24 hours

    Lift the jars out upright onto a towel, 1 inch apart, away from drafts. Leave them for 12 to 24 hours; do not tighten the bands.

  10. Check seals, label, store

    Remove the bands and press each lid: a sealed lid is concave and does not flex. Wash, label with the date, store cool, dark and dry, and use within a year.

Equipment for Canning Pumpkin Safely

Pumpkin is low-acid, so it must be pressure canned. This is the gear the tested method needs.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases.

Presto 01781 23 quart pressure canner and cooker

Presto 23-Quart Pressure Canner

Dial gauge and rack included; holds 7 quarts or 20 pints of pumpkin cubes.

Check Price on Amazon →
SEWANTA wide mouth mason jars 32 oz

Wide Mouth Mason Jars, Quart

Wide mouths make packing 1-inch cubes easy.

Check Price on Amazon →
Stainless steel canning funnels with jar lifter tongs

Canning Funnels with Jar Lifter

Fill hot jars cleanly and lift them out of the canner safely.

Check Price on Amazon →
Victorinox Fibrox Pro 8 inch chef knife

Victorinox 8-Inch Chef’s Knife

Cuts through a hard sugar pumpkin and dices even 1-inch cubes.

Check Price on Amazon →
OXO Good Grips Y peeler

OXO Good Grips Y-Peeler

Peels pumpkin wedges fast; the cubes must go in the jars peeled.

Check Price on Amazon →

Eight Rules for Pressure Canning Pumpkin Safely

The card gives the steps; these are the reasons behind them.

1

A pressure canner, every time

Low-acid pumpkin needs about 240°F, which only a pressure canner reaches. Water-bath and steam canners, ovens, slow cookers, multicookers and small pressure cookers are not safe stand-ins.

2

Check the gauge first

Have a dial gauge tested every year; many county extension offices do it. A weighted gauge needs no testing. Replace a cracked or stiff gasket before canning day.

3

Cubes, not mash

Keep the cubes at 1 inch. Bigger chunks, smaller bits and mashed pumpkin heat differently from what was tested, so the times no longer apply.

4

Hot pack, loosely

Hot pack is the only tested method for pumpkin. Pack the boiled cubes without pressing them down, so liquid can move between them.

5

Headspace and clean rims

One inch of headspace, no trapped air, clean rims. Too little headspace pushes liquid out during processing, and food on a rim can stop the lid sealing.

6

Vent, then time

Vent steam for 10 minutes first: trapped air lowers the temperature inside. Time only at full pressure, and restart from zero if it dips.

7

Cool it naturally

The slow cool-down is part of the tested process. Forcing it can pull liquid from the jars or break seals, so wait for zero, then 10 more minutes.

8

Rest, check, label

Leave the jars 12 to 24 hours, check every seal, remove the bands and date the lids. Store at 50 to 70°F and use within a year.

Canning Sugar Pie Pumpkins: Which Pumpkins Work and How Much to Buy

Small sugar pumpkins, often sold as pie pumpkins, are what USDA’s guide favors: hard rind, dense stringless flesh and a smoother pie.

PumpkinFor canningWhy
PumpkinSugar or pie pumpkinsFor canningThe best choiceWhySmall, usually 2 to 6 lb; dense, sweet, stringless flesh. USDA notes small pie types make better products.
PumpkinButternut and other winter squashFor canningSame tested processWhyThe cubed method and times cover winter squash too; blend it with pumpkin on pie day.
PumpkinLarge carving pumpkinsFor canningSafe by the same method, weak resultsWhyWatery, stringy and bland; the pie tastes thin.
PumpkinCarved, soft or moldy pumpkinsFor canningDo not canWhyCarved, long-displayed or soft-spotted pumpkins are past saving.
Peeled sugar pumpkin cut into 1-inch cubes on a wooden cutting board with a chef's knife

Peeled sugar pumpkin cut into even 1-inch cubes: the size the processing times were tested on.

How to Peel and Cube a Pumpkin Without a Fight

Halve the pumpkin and scrape out the seeds. Cut 1-inch-wide slices, lay each one flat and slice off the rind with a sharp knife or sturdy peeler, then cut even 1-inch cubes.

How Many Pumpkins for How Many Jars?

USDA’s average: about 10 pounds of pumpkin per 9 pints and 16 pounds per 7 quarts, roughly 2¼ pounds a quart. Mashed amounts are rough; measure on pie day.

JarsWhole pumpkinDrained, mashed (rough)Makes
Jars4 pints (small batch)Whole pumpkinabout 4½ lbDrained, mashed (rough)about 4 to 5 cupsMakes2 pies
Jars9 pints (full load)Whole pumpkinabout 10 lbDrained, mashed (rough)about 9 to 11 cupsMakes4 pies, plus a pint for muffins or soup
Jars7 quarts (full load)Whole pumpkinabout 16 lbDrained, mashed (rough)about 14 to 17 cupsMakes7 pies
Jars1 quart jarWhole pumpkinabout 2¼ lbDrained, mashed (rough)about 2 to 2½ cupsMakes1 pie

Pressure Canner Altitude Chart for Pumpkin: Weighted and Dial Gauges

The time never changes with altitude: 55 minutes for pints, 90 for quarts. The pressure does, because water boils cooler higher up, and it depends on the gauge.

Weighted gauge (the jiggler)

10 lb

0 to 1,000 ft

15 lb

Above 1,000 ft

Dial gauge (tested this year)

11 lb

0 to 2,000 ft

12 lb

2,001 to 4,000 ft

13 lb

4,001 to 6,000 ft

14 lb

6,001 to 8,000 ft

AltitudeWeighted gaugeDial gaugePints / quarts
Altitude0 to 1,000 ftWeighted gauge10 lbDial gauge11 lbPints / quarts55 min / 90 min
Altitude1,001 to 2,000 ftWeighted gauge15 lbDial gauge11 lbPints / quarts55 min / 90 min
Altitude2,001 to 4,000 ftWeighted gauge15 lbDial gauge12 lbPints / quarts55 min / 90 min
Altitude4,001 to 6,000 ftWeighted gauge15 lbDial gauge13 lbPints / quarts55 min / 90 min
Altitude6,001 to 8,000 ftWeighted gauge15 lbDial gauge14 lbPints / quarts55 min / 90 min

Weighted gauges come in 5, 10 and 15 pound settings, so they jump straight to 15 above 1,000 feet; a tested dial gauge climbs a pound at a time. Above 8,000 feet, the USDA dial-gauge chart stops, so ask a local extension office.

Home-Canned Pumpkin Pie Filling: From the Jar to the Pie Plate

Home-canned cubes are plain cooked pumpkin, so pie day is quick. The one difference from store-bought canned pumpkin is water: a looser purée makes a pie that weeps or never sets, so thicken it first.

Pumpkin Pie From a Jar of Home-Canned Pumpkin

One 9-inch pie · 8 slices · 425°F, then 350°F · about 1½ hr + cooling

You need

  • 1 quart jar or 2 pint jars home-canned pumpkin cubes, for 1¾ cups (425 g) thick mashed pumpkin
  • ¾ cup (165 g) packed light brown sugar
  • 1½ tsp ground cinnamon
  • ½ tsp ground ginger
  • ¼ tsp ground nutmeg
  • ⅛ tsp ground cloves
  • ½ tsp fine salt
  • 1 tsp alcohol-free vanilla
  • 2 large eggs
  • 1 cup (240 ml) evaporated milk
  • 1 unbaked 9-inch pie crust, chilled

Method

  1. Check the jar

    The lid should still be concave and sealed, with no bubbles rising, leaks or off smell on opening. Anything doubtful: do not taste it (see the checks further down).

  2. Drain and mash

    Tip the cubes into a colander for 10 minutes. Mash them with a potato masher, or blend until smooth.

  3. Thicken to canned-pumpkin texture

    Stir the mash in a wide skillet over medium heat for 5 to 10 minutes, until a spoon leaves a clear trail, or drain it in a towel-lined sieve in the fridge for 1 to 2 hours. Cool, then measure 1¾ cups.

  4. Mix the filling

    Heat the oven to 425°F (220°C) with a baking sheet inside. Whisk the pumpkin with the sugar, spices, salt and alcohol-free vanilla, then the eggs, then the evaporated milk, just until smooth.

  5. Bake in two stages

    Pour into the crust on the hot sheet. Bake 15 minutes at 425°F, then 35 to 40 minutes at 350°F (175°C), until the edge is set and the center 2 to 3 inches still wobbles (175°F).

  6. Cool, then chill

    Cool the pie on a rack for at least 2 hours, then refrigerate. Serve with whipped cream; keep leftovers in the fridge for 3 to 4 days.

The amounts match this from-scratch pumpkin pie filling recipe, which covers spice ratios, crack-free baking and milk swaps in depth. For a crustless pie that makes its own base, pour the same pumpkin into an impossible pumpkin pie.

Nutrition (approximate)

Per slice~160 cal
Protein~4g
Carbs~28g
Fat~4g

Filling only, one of 8 slices; a typical all-butter crust adds roughly 175 calories a slice. Plain drained pumpkin is about 50 calories a cup. Contains egg and dairy.

A finished pumpkin pie next to an opened jar of drained home-canned pumpkin cubes and a bowl of mashed pumpkin

Pie day: a finished pumpkin pie beside an opened jar of drained home-canned cubes and a bowl of freshly mashed pumpkin.

Pie-Day Spice Blends and Variations

Every flavor change happens after the jar is opened, never before canning. Tap a version:

Maple-Sweetened Pumpkin Pie

Swap ¼ cup of the brown sugar for ¼ cup pure maple syrup and raise the alcohol-free vanilla to 2 tsp. Cook the mash 2 minutes longer to make up for the extra liquid.

Cardamom-Forward Pie

Add ½ tsp ground cardamom with the cinnamon and cut the cloves to a pinch, for a slightly floral, aromatic pie.

Extra Ginger, Gingersnap Crust

Double the ginger to 1 tsp. Press 1½ cups (150 g) gingersnap crumbs, 5 tbsp melted butter and 1 tbsp sugar into the plate and bake 8 to 10 minutes at 350°F. Crumbs scorch at 425°F, so bake the pie at 350°F throughout, 50 to 60 minutes.

Pumpkin and Butternut Pie

Can butternut cubes on their own, same process and times. On pie day, mash 1 cup pumpkin with ¾ cup butternut for a nuttier, creamier pie.

Warm and Smoky Pumpkin Soup

Not every jar has to be pie. Soften an onion in butter, add a drained quart of cubes, 2 cups vegetable broth and ½ tsp smoked paprika, simmer 10 minutes, blend and finish with a splash of cream.

Leftover mashed pumpkin keeps 3 to 4 days in the fridge. Stir it into oatmeal, a smoothie or a batch of pumpkin pie filling muffins.

Pumpkin Filling From a Can: Canned Pumpkin vs Canned Pumpkin Pie Filling

Store-bought cans come in two kinds that are not interchangeable: 100% pumpkin is plain, while pumpkin pie filling or pie mix is already sweetened and spiced.

Can or jarSweetened and spiced?For one 9-inch pieBest for
Can or jarCanned pumpkin (100% pumpkin)Sweetened and spiced?No: plain cooked pumpkinFor one 9-inch pie1 can (15 oz), about 1¾ cups; add sugar, spices, eggs and milkBest forPies, breads, muffins, soup
Can or jarCanned pumpkin pie filling (pie mix)Sweetened and spiced?Yes: sugar and spices are inFor one 9-inch pieAdd only what its label lists, usually eggs and evaporated milkBest forPies and pie-style bars
Can or jarHome-canned pumpkin cubesSweetened and spiced?No: plain pumpkin in waterFor one 9-inch pie1 quart or 2 pints, drained, mashed and thickenedBest forPies, muffins, soup, oats
Can or jarFrozen homemade puréeSweetened and spiced?Only if seasoned before freezingFor one 9-inch pie1¾ cups, thawed and drainedBest forPies, muffins, oats

How to Use Canned Pumpkin Pie Filling

Add only what its label lists, usually eggs and evaporated milk, and bake in the crust size and at the temperatures the label gives. Skip extra sugar or spice; it already has both.

How to Use Plain Canned Pumpkin

A 15-ounce can holds about 1¾ cups, exactly what the pie card calls for. It is thicker than home-canned pumpkin, so use it straight from the can.

Freezing Pumpkin Purée and Pie Filling Instead of Canning It

Freezing is the safe home method for anything mashed, sweetened or mixed: no canner, bright color, and the filling can be seasoned ahead. One 1¾-cup portion is one pie.

  1. Cook the pumpkin

    Roast halved, seeded pie pumpkins cut side down at 375°F for 45 to 60 minutes, or steam chunks until soft.

  2. Mash and drain

    Mash or blend the flesh smooth; drain a watery batch in a towel-lined sieve.

  3. Cool it fast

    Set the pan in a sink of cold water and stir now and then.

  4. Portion, label, freeze

    Pack 1¾-cup portions, leaving ½ inch headspace in pints and 1 inch in quarts, or use flat freezer bags. Label and freeze.

WhatHow to packBest withinThaw
WhatPlain pumpkin puréeHow to packContainers or flat bags, 1¾-cup portionsBest within8 to 12 monthsThawOvernight in the fridge; pour off any liquid
WhatSweetened, spiced purée (no eggs or milk)How to packSame; note the sugar and spices on the labelBest within8 to 12 monthsThawOvernight in the fridge; add eggs and milk on pie day
WhatFully mixed filling with eggs and milkHow to packAirtight container, small headspaceBest withinAbout 1 month for the best textureThawOvernight in the fridge; whisk well before pouring
WhatBaked pumpkin pieHow to packCooled, wrapped twiceBest within1 to 2 monthsThawOvernight in the fridge; the top may weep a little

Food kept frozen at 0°F stays safe; the times are for best quality. Thaw pumpkin in the fridge, never on the counter, and pour off any liquid.

How Long Home-Canned Pumpkin Lasts, and What to Do if a Jar Won’t Seal

Store sealed jars between 50 and 70°F, away from the stove, hot pipes, sunlight and uninsulated attics or garages; heat and light fade quality.

WhatWhereHow long
WhatSealed jars of home-canned cubesWhereCool, dark, dry pantry, 50 to 70°FHow longBest within 1 year
WhatOpened jar or drained cubesWhereCovered, in the fridgeHow long3 to 4 days
WhatMashed or puréed pumpkinWhereCovered, in the fridgeHow long3 to 4 days
WhatUnbaked filling with eggs and milkWhereCovered, in the fridgeHow longUp to 2 days
WhatBaked pumpkin pieWhereIn the fridge, once cooledHow long3 to 4 days
WhatA jar that did not sealWhereIn the fridgeHow longUse within several days

Before Opening a Jar: Five Checks

  • The lid is still concave and does not flex or pop when pressed
  • No streaks of dried food run down the outside of the jar from the rim
  • No bubbles are rising in the liquid and the color looks natural
  • No liquid spurts out and nothing smells off when the jar opens
  • No mold on the pumpkin or under the lid

If any check fails, do not taste it. Bag a still-closed jar tightly and put it in the trash, out of reach of children and pets. For an opened or leaking jar, follow the cleanup steps in USDA’s home canning guide.

Jar Didn’t Seal? Troubleshooting Home-Canned Pumpkin

ProblemLikely causeWhat to do
ProblemA lid did not sealLikely causeFood on the rim, a nicked jar, too little headspace or a reused lidWhat to doWithin 24 hours: new lid, reprocess for the full time. Or refrigerate and use within several days.
ProblemLiquid level droppedLikely causePressure swings while processing, or cooling too fastWhat to doSealed jars are still safe; exposed cubes may darken. Never open a jar to top it up. Use these first.
ProblemA jar cracked in the cannerLikely causeA cold or nicked jar, or no rackWhat to doDiscard that jar’s contents. Keep jars hot and always use the rack.
ProblemPressure dipped during processingLikely causeHeat turned down too far, or a steam leakWhat to doBring it back to pressure and restart the full time from zero.
ProblemLid bulging, leaking or loose in storageLikely causeSpoilageWhat to doDo not taste it. Discard it as described above.

Home-canned pumpkin earns a place in a rotating pantry. See long-term food storage for rotation, labeling and shelf life, and the best canned foods for emergencies for what else belongs on the shelf.

Canning Pumpkin Pie Filling FAQ

Can you can pumpkin pie filling?

No. There is no tested home process for pumpkin pie filling, and USDA and the National Center for Home Food Preservation advise against it: the filling is too thick to heat reliably. Pressure-can 1-inch pumpkin cubes instead and make the filling when a jar is opened.

Can you water bath can pumpkin?

No. Pumpkin is low-acid, and a boiling-water canner only reaches about 212°F. Low-acid foods need about 240°F, which takes a pressure canner. Lemon or apple juice does not make pumpkin a water-bath food.

Can you can pumpkin purée?

Not at home. Purée, mashed pumpkin and pumpkin butter have no tested process, because their thickness varies too much. Can 1-inch cubes and purée them after opening, or freeze homemade purée in 1¾-cup portions.

Why does pumpkin have to be canned in cubes?

Liquid moves around cubes, so heat reaches the middle of the jar in a predictable, tested time. Purée packs solid and heats slowly from the outside in. The 55- and 90-minute times apply only to cubes.

How long do you pressure can pumpkin, pints vs quarts?

Pints 55 minutes and quarts 90 minutes, hot packed, timed from when the canner reaches pressure after 10 minutes of venting. The time is the same at every altitude; only the pressure changes.

What pressure do I use for canning pumpkin at high altitude?

With a weighted gauge, 10 pounds up to 1,000 feet and 15 pounds above that. With a dial gauge, 11 pounds up to 2,000 feet, 12 up to 4,000, 13 up to 6,000 and 14 up to 8,000 feet.

Can you can carving pumpkins, or only sugar pumpkins?

Sugar or pie pumpkins give the best result. Carving pumpkins can be canned by the same method, but they are watery, stringy and bland. Never can a pumpkin that has been carved or has soft spots or mold.

Can you freeze pumpkin pie filling?

Yes, and freezing is the safe way to keep it. Freeze plain or spiced purée in 1¾-cup portions for 8 to 12 months, or fully mixed filling with eggs and milk for about a month. Thaw it overnight in the fridge.

How long does home-canned pumpkin last?

Sealed jars keep their best quality for about a year in a cool, dark, dry place. Once opened, refrigerate the pumpkin, covered, and use it within 3 to 4 days.

What if a jar of pumpkin doesn’t seal?

Within 24 hours, check the rim, add a new lid and reprocess for the full time, or refrigerate the jar and use it within several days. A lid that loosens later in storage means spoilage: discard that jar untasted.

How do you use home-canned pumpkin for pie?

Drain a quart or two pints, mash, then thicken to store-bought texture. Whisk 1¾ cups with sugar, spices, 2 eggs and 1 cup evaporated milk, and bake at 425°F for 15 minutes, then 350°F for 35 to 40.

Can you add spices or sugar before canning pumpkin?

No. The tested process is plain cubes in their cooking water. Sugar, spices, juice and dairy were not part of that test, so the processing time no longer applies. Season on pie day instead.

Is canned pumpkin pie filling the same as canned pumpkin?

No. Canned pumpkin is plain. Pumpkin pie filling, or pie mix, already has sugar and spices and needs only what its label lists, usually eggs and evaporated milk. Swapping them makes a pie too sweet or too bland.

Can you can a pumpkin pie in a jar?

No. Pie in a jar, breads baked in jars and canned pie filling all lack tested processes. Refrigerate a baked pie for 3 to 4 days or freeze it for 1 to 2 months; for the pantry, can the cubes.

More Pumpkin Pies and Pantry Guides

Two fillings, a crustless pie, a use for leftovers and two guides to a pantry that rotates.

Can the pumpkin in cubes, freeze anything mashed, and keep the sugar, spice, eggs and milk for pie day. That is the whole safe system.

Save this guide to canning pumpkin pie filling for the next pumpkin harvest.

Save It on Pinterest →

© 2026 Kitchen Guide 101 · All rights reserved · Some links are affiliate links

Scroll to Top