Ducted vs Ductless Range Hoods: Which One Do You Need?
A ducted hood sends smoke, heat and moisture outside. A ductless hood filters grease and odor and blows the air back into the kitchen. Here is how they compare and which kitchens suit each.
A ducted range hood pulls cooking air through a duct to the outside. A ductless, or recirculating, hood pulls it through grease and charcoal filters and sends it back into the room.
Broan-NuTone, which makes both kinds, says range hoods should be ducted to the outside of the home.
Ducted if you can run a duct outside: it removes smoke, heat and moisture, and suits gas and heavy cooking. Ductless if you cannot: it traps some grease and odor, but heat, moisture and smoke stay in the kitchen, and the charcoal filters need replacing about every six months. Convertible hoods can do either.
A side-by-side chart, how convertible hoods work, filter upkeep, which one suits your kitchen and six picks are below.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Ducted, Ductless and Convertible Hoods Compared
All 6 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Range hood | Venting | Airflow | Filters | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hauslane Chef Series UC-PS18 30″ Under-Cabinet Range Hood | Ducted only | Capped under 350 CFM | Stainless baffles | Kitchens with a duct | $$ |
| Cosmo COS-QS75 30″ Haven Collection Ducted Under-Cabinet Range Hood | Ducted (kit for ductless) | 500 CFM | Stainless, dishwasher-safe | Most home cooking | $$ |
| Broan-NuTone GLA1303SS 30″ Under-Cabinet Range Hood, 350 CFM | Ducted or ductless | 350 CFM | Micro filters; HPF30 charcoal | Quiet kitchens | $ |
| Broan-NuTone 4130SF 30-Inch Ductless Range Hood (PrintGuard Stainless) | Ductless only | 2 speeds | Combined grease and charcoal (41F) | Rentals and replacements | $ |
| FIREGAS 30-Inch Brushless Convertible Range Hood (300 CFM, Carbon Filters Included) | Convertible | 300 CFM | CC170 carbon included | Quiet open kitchens | $ |
| Broan-NuTone 41F Replacement Grease and Charcoal Filter (97007696) | Ductless filter | Grease and charcoal in one | Replace as one piece | The Broan 4130SF | $ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ lowest in this group · $$ middle · $$$ highest.
6 Picks: Ducted, Convertible and Ductless
Two ducted hoods, two convertibles, one ductless-only hood and the filter it needs.
Hauslane Chef Series UC-PS18 30″ Under-Cabinet Range Hood
A ducted-only hood made to fit existing ductwork three ways: 6-inch round on top, or 3¼ x 10-inch rectangular on top or at the back, with all three adapters in the box. Hauslane caps the airflow under 350 CFM, below the 400 CFM line where many homes need make-up air.
The stainless baffle filters go in the dishwasher, and a delay shut-off clears the last of the smoke.
- Fits three duct types
- Stays under 400 CFM
- Dishwasher-safe baffles
- No ductless option
- Needs a duct to the outside
Cosmo COS-QS75 30″ Haven Collection Ducted Under-Cabinet Range Hood
Twin motors move 500 CFM over four speeds, and Cosmo rates it as low as 40 dB on the lowest speed with rigid ducting. It vents through a 7.5-inch round duct on top, or switches to ductless with Cosmo’s CFK5 carbon kit, sold separately.
At 500 CFM it is over the 400 CFM line, so check the local make-up air rules.
- Strong airflow
- Quiet on low
- Ductless kit available
- Needs a 7.5-inch duct
- Over 400 CFM
Broan-NuTone GLA1303SS 30″ Under-Cabinet Range Hood, 350 CFM
Broan compares its 1.5 sones on the working speed to a running refrigerator. It vents through the top or the back, or runs ductless with Broan’s HPF30 charcoal filters.
At 350 CFM it stays under the 400 CFM make-up air line, and it comes in 24 to 42-inch widths.
- Very quiet
- Ducted or ductless
- ENERGY STAR certified
- Only 2 fan speeds
- Charcoal filter sold separately
Broan-NuTone 4130SF 30-Inch Ductless Range Hood (PrintGuard Stainless)
Non-vented by design: there is no duct to run and no kit to buy. The charcoal filter comes in the box, and the 41F replacement combines the grease and charcoal filter in one piece.
It has two speeds and a rocker switch. Broan does not publish a sone rating for this model.
- No ductwork at all
- Filter in the box
- 24, 30 and 36-inch sizes
- Two speeds only
- Heat and moisture stay in the room
FIREGAS 30-Inch Brushless Convertible Range Hood (300 CFM, Carbon Filters Included)
A brushless DC motor pulls 300 CFM at under 45 dB and draws 80 watts instead of 180. The CC170 carbon filter kit is in the box, so ductless mode works on day one, with a top or rear outlet if you duct it later.
- Very quiet
- Carbon filter included
- Top or rear vent
- 300 CFM suits everyday cooking, not a wok burner
- Newer brand
Broan-NuTone 41F Replacement Grease and Charcoal Filter (97007696)
A ductless hood only works as well as its charcoal filter. KitchenAid says charcoal filters should be replaced, not cleaned, about every six months.
The 41F combines the grease and charcoal filter for the Broan 4130SF, so there is one part to change.
- One part to replace
- Made for the 4130SF
- Multi-pack options
- A repeat purchase
- Check the fit for other hoods
Ducted vs Ductless Range Hoods at a Glance
| Ducted | Ductless | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the air goes | Outside, through a duct | Back into the kitchen |
| Smoke | Removed from the home | Recirculated; it cannot vent smoke outside |
| Heat and moisture | Pushed outside | Stay in the room |
| Grease and odor | Caught by the grease filters, then vented | Partly trapped by grease and charcoal filters |
| Filters | Washable grease filters | Grease filters plus charcoal filters replaced about every 6 months |
| Install | Needs a duct through a wall, ceiling or floor | Can go nearly anywhere |
| Gas cooking | Recommended | Broan says high-BTU gas should always be ducted |
| Upkeep | Check the duct for blockages about every 6 months | Change the charcoal filters about every 6 months |
From Broan-NuTone and KitchenAid guidance.
Convertible Range Hoods: Both in One
Ducted mode
Vents out through the top or the back, like any ducted hood.
Ductless mode
Add a recirculating kit or charcoal filters, often sold separately.
Check the kit name
HPF30 for the Broan GLA1303SS, CFK5 for the Cosmo; the FIREGAS includes its CC170.
Not every hood converts
Some are ducted only, like the Hauslane, or ductless only, like the Broan 4130SF.
Renters
Run it ductless now and duct it later if a duct becomes possible.
Learn more
What a convertible range hood is, and the best convertible range hoods.
Filters and Upkeep
| Filter | Used in | Care |
|---|---|---|
| Stainless baffle | Ducted and convertible hoods | Dishwasher-safe on many models |
| Aluminum or steel mesh | Most hoods | Wash often; many go in the dishwasher |
| Charcoal (carbon) | Ductless mode only | Replace, do not wash, about every 6 months |
| Combined grease and charcoal | Some ductless hoods, like the Broan 4130SF | Replace as one piece |
Running the CIARRA ultra-slim hood ductless? It needs the CIARRA CACF006 carbon filter set, sold separately. For greasy filters, see range hood degreasing tools.
Which One Is Right for Your Kitchen?
Gas range
Ducted. Broan says high-BTU gas cooking should always be ducted outside.
Electric or induction
Either works; ducted still clears heat and steam.
Renters and condos
Ductless or convertible, when cutting a hole outside is not an option.
Frying and searing
Ducted, with enough CFM. See the range hood size guide.
No outside wall
A duct through the ceiling, or ductless.
Not sure yet
Convertible: start ductless and switch when a duct is possible.
Hanging one? See how high to mount a range hood.
How to Choose Between Ducted and Ductless
Five steps.
Find a way out
An outside wall behind the range or a path through the ceiling means ducted is possible.
Check your cooktop
Gas and high-heat cooking need ducting; KitchenAid’s guideline is 1 CFM per 100 BTU.
Mind the 400 CFM line
Hoods over 400 CFM may need make-up air under local codes.
Count the filters
Ductless hoods need new charcoal filters about every six months.
Unsure? Go convertible
A convertible hood keeps both options open.
More range hood guides: convertible range hoods, wall-mount range hoods, range hood inserts and kitchen exhaust fan size.
Ducted vs Ductless Range Hood FAQs
Is a ducted or ductless range hood better?▼
Ducted. It removes smoke, heat and moisture from the home, and Broan-NuTone says hoods should be ducted outside. Ductless is the fallback when a duct is not possible.
Do ductless range hoods actually work?▼
Partly. Their filters trap some grease and odor, but heat, moisture and smoke go back into the kitchen.
How often do you change the charcoal filter in a ductless range hood?▼
About every six months. KitchenAid says charcoal filters should be replaced, not cleaned.
Can you use a ductless range hood with a gas stove?▼
Ducted is better for gas. Broan-NuTone says high-BTU gas cooking equipment should always be ducted outside.
What is a convertible range hood?▼
A hood that works ducted or ductless. For ductless mode you add a recirculating kit or charcoal filters, such as Broan’s HPF30 or Cosmo’s CFK5.
Does a ducted range hood need make-up air?▼
Over 400 CFM, often yes. Many building codes require make-up air for hoods that can move more than 400 CFM.
Where does a ducted range hood vent?▼
Outside, through a duct in the wall, ceiling or floor.
Which is easier to install?▼
Ductless. With no duct to run it can go nearly anywhere; a ducted hood needs a path to the outside.
The Bottom Line
- Ducted: the Hauslane UC-PS18 fits three duct types and stays under 400 CFM; the Cosmo COS-QS75 moves 500 CFM.
- Convertible: the Broan-NuTone GLA1303SS for quiet, or the FIREGAS 30-Inch with its carbon filter in the box.
- Ductless only: the Broan-NuTone 4130SF, with 41F filters about every six months.
Duct it if you can, especially over gas. Go ductless or convertible when you cannot.






