Best Cookie Cutters: 7 Christmas and Everyday Sets
Seven cookie cutter sets compared: Christmas shapes, round sets, kid-friendly plastic and a Linzer cutter, with tips for clean cuts.
Best for Christmas: Ann Clark Christmas Set. Best stainless: Ateco Christmas Set. Best round set: Ateco Round Cutter Set. Best for kids: Wilton Christmas Cutters.
A good cookie cutter has a thin, even edge. Sharp edges cut cleanly, so cookies keep their shape in the oven and take icing neatly.
The best cookie cutters for Christmas are the Ann Clark Christmas set, made of thin tin-plated steel. For rust-free cutters, choose the Ateco stainless steel Christmas set, and for children, the Wilton plastic set.
All seven are sold on Amazon and compared on material, piece count and shapes.
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Kitchen Guide 101 earns from qualifying purchases.
Cookie Cutter Sets Compared
All 7 side by side. Tap any name to see it on Amazon.
| Cutter set | Material | Pieces | Shapes | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ann Clark Christmas Cookie Cutter Set | Tin-plated steel | 5 to 7 pieces | Tree, star, gingerbread, snowflake | Christmas baking | $ |
| Ateco 6-Piece Stainless Steel Christmas Cookie Cutter Set | Stainless steel | 6 pieces | Holiday shapes | Rust-free cutters | $ |
| Ateco 11-Piece Plain Round Cutter Set | Stainless steel | 11 pieces | Graduated rounds | Biscuits, sandwich cookies, pastry | $$ |
| Wilton Plastic Christmas Cookie Cutter Set, 10 Pieces | Plastic | 10 pieces | Gingerbread, candy cane, snowman | Baking with children | $ |
| Sweet Sugarbelle Cookie Cutters Mega Set | Plastic | 80 pieces | 40 shapes, letters and numbers | Every occasion | $$ |
| Fox Run Linzer Cookie Cutter Set | Stainless steel | Cutter with inserts | Window shapes | Sandwich cookies | $ |
| Ann Clark Heart Cookie Cutter Set, 5 Sizes | Tin-plated steel | 5 pieces | Graduated hearts | Valentine’s and stacking | $ |
Details are as stated on each Amazon listing at time of writing and can change. Price tiers: $ under $20 · $$ $20–40.
The 7 Best Cookie Cutters, Reviewed
Christmas sets first, then everyday and specialty cutters.
Ann Clark Christmas Cookie Cutter Set
Classic holiday shapes from a long-time American maker. Thin steel edges cut cleanly through rolled dough and leave crisp outlines for icing.
Hand wash and dry them right away so the tin plating does not rust.
- Clean cuts
- Classic shapes
- Low price tier
- Hand wash and dry
- Can bend if stored loose
Ateco 6-Piece Stainless Steel Christmas Cookie Cutter Set
A sturdier holiday set. Stainless steel resists rust, so the cutters last year after year.
Ateco makes tools for bakeries, and these hold their shape well.
- Rust resistant
- Holds shape
- Low price tier
- Fewer shapes than big sets
- Edges are sharp; supervise kids
Ateco 11-Piece Plain Round Cutter Set
The set every baker uses most. Eleven graduated rounds cut biscuits, sandwich cookies, mini tart shells and ravioli.
They nest in a storage tin, and the rolled top edge protects the hands when pressing down.
- Many sizes
- Nests in a tin
- Year-round use
- Plain shapes only
- Middle price tier
Wilton Plastic Christmas Cookie Cutter Set, 10 Pieces
Safe and cheerful for little hands. Plastic edges cut soft dough without sharp metal, so children can help.
The set includes favorite shapes like a gingerbread man, a candy cane and a snowman.
- Kid friendly
- Festive colors
- Lowest price tier
- Thicker edges cut less sharply
- Can crack if dropped
Sweet Sugarbelle Cookie Cutters Mega Set
A set for every holiday and birthday. Forty shapes plus letters and numbers cover the whole year.
The shapes are designed by a cookie decorator, so they are easy to flood and pipe.
- Huge variety
- Letters and numbers
- Easy to decorate
- Needs storage space
- Middle price tier
Fox Run Linzer Cookie Cutter Set
For jam-filled sandwich cookies. Swap the small center shapes to cut windows in the top cookie, then fill with jam.
Linzer cookies are a holiday classic and easy to make with this one tool.
- Many window shapes
- One compact tool
- Low price tier
- Inserts are small to store
- Hand wash
Ann Clark Heart Cookie Cutter Set, 5 Sizes
Five hearts from small to large. Graduated sizes stack into layered cookies or decorate a cake.
The quality is high for the price.
- Five sizes
- High quality
- Low price tier
- Hand wash and dry
- Single shape
Metal or Plastic Cookie Cutters?
| Material | Good at | Keep in mind | Picks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tin-plated steel | Thin, sharp edges and crisp shapes | Can rust; hand wash and dry | Ann Clark |
| Stainless steel | Rust resistant, lasts for years | Sharp edges | Ateco, Fox Run |
| Plastic | Safe for kids, colorful | Less sharp | Wilton, Sweet Sugarbelle |
Metal cuts the sharpest shapes. Plastic is the safest choice for young bakers.
How to Get Clean Cookie Shapes
Chill the dough
Cold dough cuts cleanly and holds its shape.
Roll evenly
Roll to about a quarter inch so cookies bake evenly.
Flour the cutter
Dip it in flour between cuts to stop sticking.
Press straight down
Do not twist; twisting drags the edges.
Chill again
Chill cut shapes for 10 minutes before baking.
Dry metal cutters
Dry them in a warm oven to prevent rust.
Decorate with this royal icing recipe and bake on the best cookie sheets.
How to Choose Cookie Cutters
Five checks before you buy.
Metal or plastic
Metal cuts sharper. Plastic is safer for kids.
About 1 inch
Deeper cutters handle thicker dough.
Rolled top
A rolled top edge is easier on the hands.
Simple outlines
Simple shapes bake without breaking.
Tin or box
Store flat so the shapes do not bend.
More baking guides: the best stovetop tea kettles, the best pizza stones and steels, the best ramekins and the best tart pans.
Cookie Cutter FAQs
What are the best cookie cutters?▼
The Ann Clark Christmas set for holiday baking, and the Ateco round set for everyday use.
Metal or plastic cookie cutters?▼
Metal cuts sharper edges; plastic is safer for children.
How do I keep dough from sticking to cookie cutters?▼
Chill the dough and dip the cutter in flour between cuts.
Why do my cookies lose their shape?▼
Warm dough or too much butter. Chill the cut shapes before baking.
Do metal cookie cutters rust?▼
Tin-plated cutters can. Hand wash and dry them right away. Stainless steel resists rust.
Are cookie cutters dishwasher safe?▼
Stainless and most plastic cutters are. Hand wash tin-plated steel.
What thickness should cookie dough be?▼
About a quarter inch for cutout cookies.
What is a Linzer cutter?▼
A cutter with removable center shapes that cuts a window in the top cookie of a jam sandwich.
The Bottom Line
- Christmas: Ann Clark Christmas Set, Ateco Christmas Set and Wilton Christmas Cutters.
- Everyday: Ateco Round Cutter Set and Sweet Sugarbelle Mega Set.
- Specialty: Fox Run Linzer Set and Ann Clark Heart Set.
A holiday set plus a round set covers most baking.
